When it comes to fluoride, a lot has changed in recent months.

Utah and Florida put a stop to fluoridation, with several more states planning to do the same. HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., said he would be telling the CDC to stop advocating the practice. The FDA moved to ban fluoride supplements.

And a massive freakout commenced among the dental establishment and public health officials – as if there were no possible way to defend tooth enamel without throwing fluoride in it.

As if no one had ever heard of proper nutrition or oral hygiene.

Really, it’s been kind of stunning to see – both the rapid pace of change and the extreme reactions to it. But it’s also gratifying. The evidence against fluoride is enough to merit concern on all sides. The risks do seem to outweigh the benefits, which recent studies suggest may be much more modest than advertised. As a recent review noted,

A 2024 Cochrane review of 21 studies conducted after 1975 indicated a much smaller benefit of CWF compared with pre-1975 studies. The authors estimated a reduction in the number of decayed, missing, and filled primary teeth of not more than 4% or possibly no benefit given the uncertainty of the estimate. These findings suggest that fluoride in water may reduce tooth decay only by about one-quarter of a tooth…. The Cochrane findings are consistent with a recent study of 6.4 million people in the United Kingdom showing that the number of decayed, missing, and filled teeth was only 2% lower among people living in fluoridated versus nonfluoridated areas. [emphasis added]

The risks of arguably greatest concern are the toxic effects of fluoride on children’s developing brains – the focus of much recent research. (We’ve blogged about some of these studies before, and early this year, a new review in JAMA Pediatrics affirmed fluoride’s link to lowered IQ.) But science has shown other negative health impacts, too. This paper from the IAOMT gives a good overview – with scientific references – of the known harms.

So if not fluoride, then what? We actually have a safer option available right now: hydroxyapatite.

Hydroxyapatite (HAP) is the mineral that makes up about 97% of your tooth enamel and a good amount of the dentin layer below. The microscopic structure of this calcium phosphate mineral features hexagonal crystal forms that align to create an incredibly organized, dense material. This special arrangement is what makes teeth so strong, allowing them to handle the daily pressures of biting and chewing across a lifetime.

HAP can be easily delivered through toothpaste, directly replacing lost minerals with the exact same material. Unlike fluoride, it’s actually biocompatible, integrating with your existing enamel. And with nano-HAP, the mineral particles are so small, they can fill microscopic imperfections in the enamel and even penetrate the tiny tubules that make up the dentin, reducing sensitivity while strengthening overall tooth structure.

Late last year, a new review of the science was published, which aimed to see if HAP is effective as a non-fluoride alternative in preventing decay. Its authors included both clinical trials and studies in which dental materials were tested in the mouth under real life conditions. Ultimately, 13 studies made the cut.

The clinical trials showed that people using HAP toothpaste had a 2.5 times higher chance of preventing cavities compared to those using a placebo paste. When comparing HAP paste head-to-head with fluoride paste, HAP performed slightly better.

The other studies showed that HAP reduced the depth of cavities more effectively than fluoride and promotes remineralization at comparable levels. HAP was also found to reduce the amount of bacteria clinging to tooth surfaces by about 65% compared to control groups.

Whether you’re wanting to switch from fluoride to something more natural or are already fluoride-free but want to support the ongoing natural remineralization of your teeth, there’s no shortage of HAP toothpastes for you to choose from. Some of the most popular brands include Risewell, Boka, and Dr. Jen. Be aware, though, that some varieties from some brands contain both fluoride and HAP. Opt for the fluoride-free.

As the science shows, hydroxyapatite alone is enough.