Through the past several years, most of us have experienced that shift from dread to disbelief at the grocery checkout, seeing the total climb higher and higher and higher still. It’s had families at every income level looking for ways to be smarter with their spending. Even those who aren’t struggling financially have likely taken a harder look at where their food dollars go.

Among the first purchases to get reconsidered? Organic produce, meat, and dairy.

It’s a totally understandable choice, too. Organic food tends to cost more – sometimes significantly more. On average, according to one analysis, organic produce costs roughly 53% more than conventional. Fully one quarter “of the 68 organic items reviewed [for that analysis] cost at least 75.0% more.”

But is ditching organic merely trading short-term savings for long-term health costs? Well, it depends on what we’re actually asking when we wonder – as a recent piece over at the BBC did – if organic is, in fact, “healthier” or “better for you.”

Are we talking about nutritional content – the belief that organic foods contain more vitamins, minerals, and beneficial compounds? Or are we talking about what’s NOT in organic food – fewer pesticide residues, no routine antibiotics, and so on? What about adjacent factors that can affect food quality, such as farming practices that support soil health and environmental sustainability, or animal welfare standards?

Ultimately, the answer to “is organic healthier?” depends partly upon which aspects you think matter most.

The BBC article does a pretty good job of laying out the current state of our knowledge, such as less pesticide contamination of organic produce – one big reason why we favor organic ourselves. The less burden we put on our bodies, the better. Other studies suggest that organic crops may have slightly better nutritional profiles, though results from study to study have been inconsistent.

One reason for that may stem from the fact that quite a few variables can affect nutrition. Soil quality is one of the big ones. Industrial chemical-centric farming depletes nutrients in the earth crops are grown in, and this loss is one of several reasons why, as one 2024 paper put it, “there has been an alarming decline in food quality and a decrease in a wide variety of nutritionally essential minerals and nutraceutical compounds in imperative fruits, vegetables, and food crops” over the past 60 years.

On the upside, research also has shown that farming practices that build soil health tend to produce more nutrient-dense food. For instance, a 2022 study on regenerative farming methods found that for all of the crops they compared – mostly plant but also meat – there were

differences in micronutrient and phytochemical concentrations that suggest soil health is an under appreciated influence on nutrient density, particularly for phytochemicals not conventionally considered nutrients but nonetheless relevant to chronic disease prevention. Likewise, regenerative grazing practices produced meat with a better fatty acid profile than conventional and regional health-promoting brands.

Simply, healthy, biologically active soils support better nutrient uptake by plants, and that has effects down the line, including the nutrient-density of the food that reaches both livestock and the food that reaches your plate. This applies to conventionally grown food, as well as organic, although it does seem as though regenerative practices are more prevalent on organic farms…

To be continued