Last month, a coalition of Native American, environmental, and consumer groups issued the Red River Declarations, demanding that the US Indian Health Service “stop defying FDA recommendations and international law” and stop using mercury amalgam to fill the teeth of Native Americans.

That would certainly be a big step forward. Amalgam use is plummeting in the US. Countries around the world are banning it completely. Still, despite FDA guidance against using the material in well over half the population, it remains in use, particularly when our government (or dental insurance) is footing the bill.

Mercury amalgam is cheap, after all, and fillings made from it are quicker and easier to place. A dentist who places mercury fillings can see more patients and do more procedures in a single day than if they were placing tooth-colored composite fillings. And dental insurance will cover it.

Still, if you were to ask a conventional dentist why they continue to use amalgam, you’re apt to hear about how strong and durable amalgam is. They might add that this is especially important in the back teeth, since those fillings need to withstand the forces of chewing – overlooking the fact that each time you bite, small amounts of mercury are released from them.

That mercury doesn’t just disappear. Much of it is inhaled and introduced to the bloodstream via the lungs. Some may eventually be excreted; some may settle in organs such as the brain, kidneys, and liver. All of it is toxic and over time can contribute to a wide variety of systemic health issues. In fact, autopsy studies have shown that dental amalgam is the source of 60-95% of all mercury deposits found in the human body.

While research and clinical reports suggest that removing these fillings and replacing them with biocompatible alternatives can alleviate symptoms, why not just avoid them in the first place by using safer dental materials?

While it used to be true that amalgam was the stronger and more durable material, that was decades ago, when composite was something new. It’s no longer the case, though, as a new study in the journal Bioengineering shows.

Working with dental records from a large healthcare provider in Israel covering roughly 650,000 patients, the researchers looked at the longevity of both composite and amalgam fillings that had been placed in back teeth between 2014 and 2022. Any filling that had to be redone was considered “failed.” So were filled teeth that were later root canaled or extracted.

Of the 113,281 amalgam fillings that had been placed, almost 20,000 failed. That’s a failure rate of 17.49%. Comparatively, 65,943 out of 555,671 composite fillings failed, or just under 12%.

That’s a very big difference, to say the least.

The current study found no evidence of the superiority of amalgam over composite restorations. At a time when a global environmental decision has been made to reduce the use of mercury, it seems that there are no clinical reasons to continue treatments with amalgam alloy in dentistry. We found that more composite restorations are being placed; this may be due to aesthetic concerns, generally higher compensation, or because some healthcare providers believe that composites are safer. This study, based on big data, indicates that composite restorations have a lower replacement rate than amalgams, and there is now strong evidence to end the long-standing debate on the longevity of amalgam and composite materials. Hence, we can strongly support the Minamata recommendations for the use of composite resin materials only. [emphasis added]

With the whole European Union set to join many other countries around the world when its total amalgam ban takes effect on January 1, 2025, it’s beyond time for the US to take action and follow suit.